Been neglecting this so let's see if there is anything worth sharing with you guys
You guys should review "Selkie." It's pretty bad. Selkiecomic.com
There's this site I found through Twitter that has all these poorly-thought-out superhero characters – Ultimate Man, Super Soul, Charisma Grey, and Chrome Justice (the latter two have yet to star in any comics of their own). I think the person who made these is trying to do what Marvel and DC did back in the silver age, but he doesn't seem to have any idea what he's doing. If you decide to to them, I would suggest probably covering all of them in the same article, since they all have the same problems.
This one is actually pretty interesting in it's badness.
Hello!I google searched for webcomic reviewers and found your site! I read a couple of your wikipages and I like your style of reviewing!I have myself set up a webcomic and now I feel I have enough comicstrips posted to try to get some Reviews and feedback from comic critics around the web. It is a bit niched towards hospital staff but my aim(and hope) is that most people would find parts of it funny.I you have time to check it out I would be more than happy!www.elephantintheor.combest regardsMikael Plymoth
A lot of people have been sending us review requests for themselves wanting pointers
I'm Shkelliton, or Shannon, whatever you prefer. I am a frequent purveyor and enjoy-er of the reviews on the Bad Webcomic Wiki because man, you guys are hilarious. Honestly, the reviews are amazing and give legitimate points with just the right amount of sass and possible asshole-ry (which isn't a problem) to make it an enjoyable read. I don't care if you get hate or even come across as jerks - you're right 99% of the time and I respect your writing abilities. Now, I write a webcomic myself, which should be coming to a close soon enough. It's a short one that I hope to print at some point, so I had an idea: have the most brutal critics I know of to review and critique what I have. Rip it apart, tear it limb from limb, lemme know what I need to or should fix. Now personally I hope you derive some enjoyment out of it, but I wasn't complimenting your ability to critique to butter you up. I truly want to know what I can do - panelling issues, character voices and cliches, pacing of the story, plot holes, whatever. Generally speaking I script out my stories to what I see as a finished product, but I didn't do that for this one because it's a short one. Anyways, it should be over in a month or two, I hope you'll check it out and shred it to pieces like you do so well once it's done! Regards,Shannon/Shkelliton http://tapastic.com/series/dreamward
I like your work. Anyone willing to say the emperor has no clothes is okay in my book. Anyway, I've come across a couple poorly-drawn abominations from the same author that I don't think you've gotten to yet. Dragon City and the more recent Jix. Haven't read the latter, but I'm assuming it has all the same problems as the former.
HERE'S SOME REALLY BAD HATE MAIL!
I stumbled upon your site looking for a story summary for a comic you've labeled bad and while your site lists a few comics I really like, I like what you've got going. You're less irrational than I expected. (That's not to say I disagree with your points about the comics I do like. I still like them despite unrealistic characters, unclear story, etc. They're webcomics after all; not a NYT bestseller. You are 100% about Jeph Jacques being a jackass tho. )Heres the part you can turn off and go into hate-mail-response mode: I just think your site is pointless. Some Webcomics are bad for a number of valid reasons. And...? Should I stop liking it? Should the author stop creating content that people like? That goes for your content as well. I personally don't like it but other people do. And maybe that's your reasoning, i don't know. But on the surface, who really cares if you think the comic sucks and are smug and douchey about it? I guess the answer would be people who are also so butthurt about the contents existence they seek out others who agree with them.The problem is that these are just normal dudes who like writing a webcomic. That's where it isn't cool. But I know you don't care. This is just a message from one hater to another. I don't have to visit your site or care it exists but you're stuck with your piles of garbage. Kind of like AVGN for webcomics but at least he's funny.:D
Okay this next comic suggesting is some next level bad shit
I don't know if it's the sort of thing that merits a review, but holy shit, this thing is bad
http://www.hugocomics.comAuthor seems like an okay guy, if a bit disconnected from reality.
The rest was not woth posting here besides a string of crazy emails directed at me personally by someone I never heard of calling me a racist