Remove this ad

avatar

Shan

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,964

#121 [url]

Oct 25 15 5:39 PM

What's the convention on adding things to other people's reviews. I added one image and a one line quip to Gamer Gate Life but there's nothing to indicate that oddguy didn't write or add that last bit. Are we supposed to make that clear when we do things like that or only do so if we radically rewrite or add to something. I personally thought it doesn't rate a mention but since I am modiying someone else's work (albeit slightly), I thought I should bring it up.

Quote    Reply   
Remove this ad
avatar

Long Tom

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,101

#122 [url]

Oct 25 15 7:01 PM

Our reviews are essentially group projects.  I've made most minor modifications to reviews bo others, and people make such modifications to mine.  Which is fine with me as they typically put in things I didn't know about or hadn't thought of.  For major things like putting in a biography of the webcomic author, I say the other person wrote it, since Plarbiman and Oddguy know certain things about these people that I don't.  I did mention completing the review of Furthia High and adding greatly to The Luiigian's review of Sabrina-Online, which I felt said more about the author than about his comic.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Shan

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,964

#123 [url]

Oct 25 15 7:35 PM

Let me rephrase that: "I personally thought [giving myself credit/marking I added a small bit to the end of the review] doesn't rate a mention but since I am modifying someone else's work (albeit slightly), I thought I should bring it up. It was just a bit about his pitch as to why you should sign up to his Patreon which went nicely with what oddguy wrote beforehand. (I get the guy is joking on his Patreon but as with all jokes, YMMV).

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Shan

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,964

#126 [url]

Oct 28 15 8:15 PM

Not that I know of. Well, I guess I'm suggesting it. Like before, I'll write the first draft and post it in the forums. Basically falls into the same pit that Murry and Lewy did, though not as bad. Well, not quite. Sam the Black Knight is the other one.

I'll also keep working on my Exiern rewrite, Dark Reflections and tinker a bit more where needed with Murry and Lewy, so just letting you all know I haven't forgotten about those and will keep at those until I think they're passable.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Shan

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,964

#127 [url]

Nov 13 15 9:08 AM

OK, I Dream of Jeanie Bottle and Adam4d.com are largely done. Not completely ready though but the bulk of the heavy lifting is done. Still needs some stuff added and cleaning up though before you could call them complete. Should be soon though. At the very worst, I'll make a point of chipping away at what's left on a regular basis.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Shan

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,964

#128 [url]

Nov 20 15 9:06 PM

OK, I Dream of Jeanie Bottle ready for main page listing. Adam4d.com, still working on it. Need another week or so for that one (other things going on holding me up). Wish to request "The Melvin Chronicles" (I Dream of Jeanie Bottle spinoff) and "Sailor Sun" (from the same author as I Dream of Jeanie bottle and some sort of metacommentary on all these gender swap comics).

Since by then I'll have reviewed or rereviewed at least half of the 910cmx comics on this site, I might as well ride that nuclear bomb right into the heart of the swarm and do an article on 910cmx itself. Question though, do we do that sort of thing? I saw we had a review for Snafu, which seems to be a site that links to other sites, 910cmx seems to be a bit like that since they discuss a lot of webcomics that are reviewed here.

http://melvin.jeaniebottle.com/

http://sailorsun.org/

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Shan

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,964

#130 [url]

Nov 21 15 10:58 PM

OK, I'll toss 910cmx on my to do list. Thank you.

Quote    Reply   
Remove this ad
avatar

Swift

Casual User

Posts: 5

#131 [url]

Dec 3 15 11:49 AM

Is the first post and the list up to date? I saw Comics in Disguise, and must admit, being the marginal Transformers fan I am, I was reading that story for a while. To think we have gotten to a point where an official Transformers comic is now ripping CID off and made their version of Thundercracker the same almost-human average joe... my heart weeps.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Nomstuff

Regular User

Posts: 151

#133 [url]

Feb 10 16 3:10 PM

Swift wrote:
Is the first post and the list up to date? I saw Comics in Disguise, and must admit, being the marginal Transformers fan I am, I was reading that story for a while. To think we have gotten to a point where an official Transformers comic is now ripping CID off and made their version of Thundercracker the same almost-human average joe... my heart weeps.

I was gonna take that one, but it bored me to death and I gave up. feel free to take it if you want. 

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Shan

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,964

#134 [url]

Feb 23 16 1:55 AM

I posted this elsewhere on a target for deletion thread (said target was deleted) but I thought I should also post it here as it's even more appropriate for this thread. (edit: I *knew* one was missing from when I brought this up in the other thread, looks like Evon was already taken outside and nuked.)

I think these either need to be completed or deleted, I was wondering what everyone else thought.

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Unfinished_reviews_and_articles

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Ballerina_Mafia (Nothing done from Ratings Summary down included)

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Belch_Dimension_Comics (Nothing really done from Downfall down included - Downfall section negligible)

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Comics_In_Disguise (Largely incomplete, I see this one's still being discussed)

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Crazy_Sunshine (This one kind of looks finished - perhaps too long if anything. What do we do with this one?)

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Rival_Angels (all but incomplete template)

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/User:Natsa/Mandatory_Fun_Day (Largely incomplete)

Articles - Don't know what these are for exactly.

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/User:Turcano/Bad_Webcomic_Enablers

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/The_animu

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/User:Turcano/The_Revenge_Fantasy

 

Last Edited By: Shan Feb 23 16 1:58 AM. Edited 1 time.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Long Tom

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,101

#136 [url]

Feb 23 16 6:53 PM

Shan wrote:
I posted this elsewhere on a target for deletion thread (said target was deleted) but I thought I should also post it here as it's even more appropriate for this thread. (edit: I *knew* one was missing from when I brought this up in the other thread, looks like Evon was already taken outside and nuked.)

I think these either need to be completed or deleted, I was wondering what everyone else thought.

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Unfinished_reviews_and_articles

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Belch_Dimension_Comics (Nothing really done from Downfall down included - Downfall section negligible)

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Comics_In_Disguise (Largely incomplete, I see this one's still being discussed)

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Rival_Angels (all but incomplete template)

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/User:Natsa/Mandatory_Fun_Day (Largely incomplete)

Articles - Don't know what these are for exactly.

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/User:Turcano/Bad_Webcomic_Enablers

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/The_animu

http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/User:Turcano/The_Revenge_Fantasy



 

I will complete Ballerina Mafia.  Certainly a webcomic by good old immelman cannot be ignored by this website-he alerady gave us an abomination like Concession, though this seems not so terrible.

Last Edited By: Long Tom Mar 3 16 4:22 AM. Edited 1 time.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Nomstuff

Regular User

Posts: 151

#137 [url]

Mar 2 16 7:59 PM

If Swift isn't gonna do Comics in Disguise, then you can just delete it, I don't have the motivation to slog through the rest of that, it's not even bad enough to make me hate it.

scratch that, I'll finish it now. 

EDIT: So, Hathor the Cow Godess died, RIP, and in it's place has sprung "MamaIS" I can only find a few choice strips on the new site, but have no real desire to go digging for more. 

So, if anyone wants this, it's all yours. 

http://www.mamaiscomic.com/

Last Edited By: Nomstuff Mar 4 16 6:14 AM. Edited 2 times.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Nomstuff

Regular User

Posts: 151

#138 [url]

Mar 4 16 9:40 PM

The site hates me.

Anywho, http://www.stumbleupon.com/content/2FGl0s/lists  is the only Drips'n'dregs comic I can find, still nothing for Zombie Bitch Night, I've checked everywhere I can think of.

I have a folder full of shitty webcomic, specifically for the purposes of reviewing on this site, would it be okay if I dumped them all in one thread and solicited opinions on their worthiness for inclusion on the site?

I just don't wanna flood the site with one thread per comic.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Shan

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,964

#139 [url]

Apr 1 16 12:55 PM

I'm ready to get back on the horse after almost snapping my mind with my last effort. Requesting clearance to go ahead with a review of The Melvin Chronicles (they took the most dull subplot in the extremely morally suspect I Dream of a Jeannie Bottle and turned it into an extremely dull webcomic) and Sailor Sun, which seems to be some sort of central meta-nexus for IDOAJB, TMC, The Wotch/The Wotch Cheer and I'm fairly sure many of our favourites from 910cmx. Not quite so bad as at least it's in on the joke where genderbending is used as a plot device but it still has some very questionable ideas IMO.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

Long Tom

Living Spambot

Posts: 1,101

#140 [url]

Apr 1 16 4:25 PM

Shan wrote:
I'm ready to get back on the horse after almost snapping my mind with my last effort. Requesting clearance to go ahead with a review of The Melvin Chronicles (they took the most dull subplot in the extremely morally suspect I Dream of a Jeannie Bottle and turned it into an extremely dull webcomic) and Sailor Sun, which seems to be some sort of central meta-nexus for IDOAJB, TMC, The Wotch/The Wotch Cheer and I'm fairly sure many of our favourites from 910cmx. Not quite so bad as at least it's in on the joke where genderbending is used as a plot device but it still has some very questionable ideas IMO.

Sure, why not?  But in your case, avoid webcomics that you hate too much.

Quote    Reply   
Remove this ad
Add Reply

Quick Reply

bbcode help